A practical guide to adding homes without demolishing the existing house
Yes. Depending on your municipality, zoning and property layout, you may be able to keep your existing home while adding a secondary suite, laneway house, coach house, garden suite or another form of infill housing. You do not always need to demolish to create additional dwellings.
What are my options?
1. Keep the house and add a secondary suite
A legal suite within the existing home can be one of the simplest ways to add a dwelling, provided the house and the proposed alterations meet local regulations and building-code requirements.
2. Keep the house and build a detached dwelling
Some municipalities allow a laneway house, coach house, garden suite or rear-yard home alongside an existing principal dwelling. The type, size and location of the new building depend on zoning and site conditions.
3. Convert or retain a qualifying character house
Vancouver provides specific opportunities for eligible character houses, including multiple conversion dwellings and infill. Additional floor area may be considered, but approval is discretionary and subject to City guidelines.
Example: a character home retention project in Vancouver
VictorEric is currently transforming a 1926 character home on East 13th Avenue in Vancouver into a Multiple Conversion Dwelling. The proposal involves converting the existing single-family dwelling into a two-family dwelling and adding an infill dwelling in the rear yard.
As part of the construction process, our team undertook a house lift to accommodate the new development while retaining the existing home. By choosing to preserve and renovate the original structure rather than demolish it, our client can benefit from additional floor area allowances and certain zoning relaxations available through the City of Vancouver’s character home retention provisions.
This project demonstrates how retaining a qualifying character home can create opportunities for increased housing density while preserving the architectural character of Vancouver’s established neighbourhoods.
What does Vancouver allow?
In Vancouver’s R1-1 zone, an existing single detached house may be retained with eligible secondary suite or laneway house development. Qualifying character houses may also be considered for conversion or infill housing under separate regulations.
For eligible character house retention projects, the R1-1 District Schedule provides a potential floor space ratio (FSR) of up to 0.85 for infill. Other character-house relaxations may apply depending on the proposal. These are not guaranteed entitlements: the City reviews character merit, layout, permitted uses and applicable guidelines.
For character house conversion and infill projects in Vancouver’s R1-1 zone, the number of dwellings allowed is subject to zoning regulations, site conditions and design requirements.
What about other BC municipalities?
Opportunities are not limited to Vancouver. The examples below show common retention pathways; each property still requires a zoning review.
| Municipality | Potential retention pathway |
|---|---|
| Burnaby | Existing house with additional small-scale housing where the applicable residential zoning and site layout permit. |
| Richmond | Existing home with an eligible secondary suite, coach house or other permitted accessory housing form. |
| Surrey | Existing single-family home + secondary suite + coach house or garden suite (a three-unit example published by the City). |
| Coquitlam | Existing home with eligible secondary suite, carriage house or garden cottage under applicable zoning. |
| North Vancouver / West Vancouver | Accessory dwelling options such as coach houses or detached suites in eligible areas; rules differ between the City and District. |
| New Westminster | Laneway or carriage housing on eligible residential lots. |
What Should You Check Before Starting the Design?
A feasibility review checks what you can build, how much space is allowed, and where buildings can go. It also checks access, parking, safety, trees, property restrictions, water and sewer services, upgrades needed to the existing house, and required permits.
Is keeping the house the better financial option?
Keeping your house may cost less than tearing it down and rebuilding. However, repairs, safety upgrades and improvements to water and sewer connections can add up. You may also need to remove hazardous materials, such as asbestos. Compare the total cost of both options, including any lost rental income, before deciding.
Keep Your House or Rebuild?
Keeping your house may cost less if it is in good condition and there is room to add more homes. Rebuilding may make more sense if it needs major repairs or limits what you can build.
Compare the full cost of both options, including permits, lost rent and unexpected repairs, against what the finished homes could sell or rent for.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to demolish my existing house to add another dwelling?
Not necessarily. Depending on your zoning and site layout, you may be able to retain the house and add a legal secondary suite, laneway home, coach house, garden suite or another permitted dwelling. The permitted building configuration must be confirmed for your property.
Does my home need to be a character house?
No. Character-house status is relevant to certain Vancouver infill and floor-area incentives, but many municipalities also have options for retaining ordinary existing homes. A house that does not qualify for character retention may still be eligible for a suite or detached accessory dwelling.
How many additional units can I build?
It depends on your municipality, zoning, lot area and dimensions, existing floor area and proposed building arrangement. A zoning allowance for multiple units does not automatically mean that all of them can be added while keeping the existing house.
Can I live in my house while the new dwelling is being built?
Potentially. Occupancy depends on construction access, utility connections, safety requirements and whether upgrades to the existing house require temporary relocation. This should be reviewed during project planning.
Can I sell the new dwelling separately?
Not always. Separate ownership may require strata subdivision or another approved legal arrangement. For example, Vancouver laneway houses are generally not separately strata-titled from the principal house. Confirm the ownership options before deciding on a project.
Will retaining the house save money?
It can reduce demolition and replacement costs and may preserve rental income. However, foundations, wiring, fire and life-safety upgrades, building envelope work, and servicing can offset those savings. Compare a retention-and-infill budget with a demolition-and-rebuild budget before proceeding.
What costs should I expect beyond construction?
Allow for design and consultant fees, permits, municipal charges, utility connections, site work, hazardous-material assessment where required, and a contingency for unknown existing conditions. The renovation cost ranges above are preliminary allowances, not fixed quotations.
What is the first step?
Start with a site-specific feasibility review of zoning, current house location and condition, available floor area, trees, access and servicing. That review can establish realistic options before detailed design begins.
Let’s Look at Your Lot
Whether keeping your house makes sense is a question with a real answer, and it comes from your lot dimensions, your house’s condition and what you want out of the project. We have been a Design + Build firm in Vancouver for over twenty-five years, and because our design team and our construction team work under one roof, the feasibility numbers we give you are the numbers we build to.
Send us your address and a few photos of your house. We will tell you what your lot allows, whether your house qualifies for retention incentives, and how the two options compare. Let’s create your Amazing Space.
Regulatory references
- City of Vancouver – R1-1 District Schedule
- City of Vancouver – Character House Retention Guidelines
- City of Surrey – Small-Scale Multi-Unit Housing
- Province of BC – Small-Scale Multi-Unit Housing
Note: This information is based on current zoning regulations and is subject to change. It does not confirm development rights for any specific property. Applicable zoning, City interpretations, and permitting requirements must be verified on a site-specific basis.